Seismology for schools: five lessons

Lesson 4. Intensity and intensity scales

Case file 04 · Intensity and intensity scales

One earthquake. One town in ruins, another asleep. Why?

The answer is not in the magnitude. It is written in Roman numerals, from I to XII.
  • Lesson 4 of 5Intensity and intensity scales
  • 45 minutestheory, practice, questions
  • Ages 14 to 17a screen or phones
  • 0 clues opened
Briefing

What you will find out

The same earthquake can break windows in one town and go unnoticed in another. In this lesson the class learns what intensity is, how an intensity scale works and why it is not the same as magnitude.

  • the difference between magnitude and intensity
  • the twelve degrees of the EMS-98 scale and its link to MSK-64
  • what makes the intensity higher or lower at a place
  • how intensity lets us study earthquakes of the past
Clue 1

What people and buildings feel

Magnitude tells how big the earthquake was at its source. But two towns at different distances feel the same earthquake very differently. To describe the shaking at a particular place, seismologists use intensity.

Intensity describes the effects of an earthquake at one place: what people felt, what happened to objects, buildings and the ground. It is written in Roman numerals. One earthquake has one magnitude but many intensities.

IXVIIIVIIVIone earthquake, one magnitude,many intensities

Lines that join places of equal intensity are called isoseismals. The intensity is usually highest near the epicentre and falls with distance, but not evenly.

Clue 2

The twelve degrees

An intensity scale is a list of degrees, each with a description of typical effects. In Europe the standard is the European Macroseismic Scale, EMS-98, with twelve degrees. It grew out of the MSK-64 scale, which was used in Armenia and the whole Soviet Union and is still found in older reports and maps.

Experiment

Move through the twelve degrees of EMS-98.

Other countries use other scales: the Modified Mercalli scale (MMI, twelve degrees) in the United States, and the JMA scale in Japan, which has its own degrees from 0 to 7. A degree on one scale is not exactly the same as on another.

Clue 3

What decides the intensity

  • Magnitude: a larger source shakes harder and over a wider area.
  • Distance and depth: the farther from the source, the weaker the shaking. A shallow earthquake is stronger at the epicentre than a deep one of the same magnitude.
  • Ground: soft soil and river sediments shake more than solid rock.
  • Buildings: degrees VI and above are judged by damage, and damage depends on how well the buildings were built.

In the Spitak earthquake of 1988 the magnitude was Ms 6.8 and the greatest intensity reached X on the MSK-64 scale. Many frame and panel buildings collapsed, while well-built masonry often survived: the same shaking, different buildings.

Intensity is also how we study earthquakes that happened before seismographs. Chronicles and old reports describe the effects; from them historians and seismologists estimate the intensity and then the likely magnitude. This is how the strong earthquakes of Armenia since the ninth century are known.

You can help with this today. If you feel an earthquake, tell us what you noticed: Did you feel it?

Science file

Intensity and instruments

Intensity is macroseismic: it is assigned from observations, not read from an instrument. Its strength is that it needs no seismograph, so it works for any place and any century. Its weakness is that it depends on the observer and on the buildings.

Engineers therefore also use quantities measured by strong-motion instruments (accelerographs): the peak ground acceleration (PGA), the peak ground velocity (PGV) and the response spectrum, which shows how buildings with different natural periods respond to the same shaking. Higher intensities correspond, on average, to higher accelerations and velocities, but the scatter is large, so one cannot be converted exactly into the other.

This is also the idea behind the multi-pendulum seismometers designed by A. Nazarov, whose name our institute bears: a set of pendulums with different periods records directly how structures of different stiffness would respond. See the Nazarov museum.

Final lock

Four questions to close the case

0 of 4 correct

Which statement is true?

“Many people are frightened and run outdoors; fine cracks appear in plaster.” Which EMS-98 degree is this?

Two villages are at the same distance from the epicentre. One stands on rock, the other on soft river sediments. Where is the intensity likely to be higher?

How do we know the size of an earthquake that happened in the year 893?

For the teacher: plan, answers, discussion

Plan (45 minutes)

  • 0–10 min. Part 1. Ask: where were you during the last earthquake you felt, and what did you notice?
  • 10–25 min. Part 2 with the slider. Give groups three short descriptions and let them assign a degree.
  • 25–35 min. Part 3. Open the Spitak page and the list of strong earthquakes.
  • 35–45 min. Questions and discussion.

Answers

  • Group task, examples: “Dishes rattled, some people outdoors noticed nothing”: IV. “Chimneys fell, cracks in many walls”: VII. “Hanging lamp swung, only a few people noticed”: III.
  • Questions: 2, 2, 2, 2.

Questions for discussion

  • Why are Roman numerals used for intensity and ordinary numbers for magnitude?
  • Could a magnitude 5 earthquake produce a higher intensity than a magnitude 6? When?
  • Why does the quality of buildings change the intensity that is assigned?

Data and examples: CHARNET seismic network, Institute of Geophysics and Engineering Seismology after A. Nazarov, Gyumri. iges.am